Declined Prevent Blu from breaking red secrets? (1 Viewer)

[T0aster]

The reason im putting this on here is cause ive been through the guards section of rules about twice now and cant see anything about this.
I feel like this should be put in place, as it can encourage reds to rebel
The only reason that i would say Blu/guards can break these is when it is necessary for that guard to survive, such as escaping reds or getting out of a trapped area such as a vent teleport

If this is already a part of the rules, please correct me. I might have just missed it.

 

[SirKrookodile]

Old suggestion of mine that is pretty much the same thing. Pretty much unless it's a freeday it falls under being inactive.

Declined Thread '[JB] Blus and Secrets.'

Apr 13, 2024

Hello everybody, My name is Sir Krookodile. I have recently became aware of a lack of a rule that I always believed existed. That is that there is no mention of Blus being forbidden from doing red secrets, which would include doing an escape secret to throw the round, disabling a red secret so reds are unable to attempt it. Etc etc. I feel this should be pretty open shut. It puts rebelling reds at a major disadvantage, making it far more difficult for them to succeed at rebelling.
In short, I prepose this should be added to the rules: "Blus may not Activate red secrets."
It's...

• SirKrookodile
• jailbreak
• Replies: 27
• Forum: Archive

• 
• 

 

[Sammy Slamma Jamma]

I have also suggested this it will not happen and after reading the comments on my suggestion I agree with the rule as it stands

Declined Thread '[JB] Make Breaking Vents Against Rules for BLUs'

Nov 18, 2024

Hi. I've noticed a problem. While technically covered under the server rules under:
"c) General disruptive behaviour
This includes a number of things, such as: prolonging rounds without due cause; teaming with a player on the opposing team; excessive spawn killing; blocking people’s sight; willingly assisting hackers by healing them; encouraging rule-breaking or otherwise grievous acts."

Breaking vents is not against the rules for BLUs. I feel like this should be specified for BLUs, to prevent griefing. Maybe something such as:

Guards may not break vents, windows, etc. leading...

• Sammy Slamma Jamma
• Replies: 9
• Forum: Archive

 

[CutePyro0]

breaking red secrets is being a inactive guard in most situations so voted no

in the event your chasing a rebel for example into armoury the secret likley is already broken so u can still use it

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

Reminder everyone! Would this rule lead over to breakable as a whole? Would breaking any form of breakable be apart of the rule? Are we going back to the days where blues cannot break windows or break objects in maps? Are we going to start having reports on the forums for a blue breaking a box on a map?

 

[Mehgend]

So the name of the thread and the polls name were conflicting. Ive changed the poll title to match that of the thread name. If you voted please take this into consideration and re-read the poll title.

 

[PistolPoppinSince02]

Title- "Prevent Blu from breaking red secrets?"
Poll- "Should Blu/Guards be allowed to break red secrets?"​

I voted Yes, because presumably that is to the poll itself, and not to the title.
Yes, Blus should be allowed to break Red secrets.
​

 

[CutePyro0]

Title- "Prevent Blu from breaking red secrets?"​

Poll- "Should Blu/Guards be allowed to break red secrets?"​

I voted Yes, because presumably that is to the poll itself, and not to the title.​

Yes, Blus should be allowed to break Red secrets.​

​

it would need to depend on the secret for example breaking a red ammo secret should be banned

 

[Mehgend]

Title- "Prevent Blu from breaking red secrets?"​

Poll- "Should Blu/Guards be allowed to break red secrets?"​

I voted Yes, because presumably that is to the poll itself, and not to the title.​

Yes, Blus should be allowed to break Red secrets.​

I changed the poll title. Didnt go through the first attempt for some reason.

 

[PokeMario17]

I'm 99% sure there's already a rule stating that if a Blue participates in breaking Red secrets, they are labeled as an Inactive Guard in that round until they return to the rest of the group with the current activities.

That being said, I'm also pretty sure they're also allowed to break Red secrets at the request of a Red's DR, such as the Boat secret in... that one map I can't remember the name of.

Voted Yes because the rule is already in place, though no point in changing it to be honest.

 

[Bananawastaken]

No this is really bad, a lot of map secrets like orangers secret are balanced BECAUSE of it being breakable.

Your concerns are already covered under being an inactive guard

 

[T0aster]

After reading the comments, I have changed my view and think that this should be declined. Simply due to how confusing it would be to report and what would be defined as a “red secret” for each map.

Also sry about the conflicting poll, idk why I did it like that. Thanks Mehgend for fixing it.

 

[Bananawastaken]

Declining at OPs request