Declined replace jb_supermario_v16e with b2 (1 Viewer)

[Nergal Nergalton]

is the idea to replace the current supermario or to have both in rotation at the same time? if the latter is the case, maybe a name change for the CS port from Rebel would be nice

Read the thread title.

 

[Gale]

Its fine, but not worth replacing supermario

 

[Bananawastaken]

Declining due to poll results, while I appreciate your attempts, supermario is a major map for us and I don't think your update matches the quality (both design and polish) Semi set with the current version.
I think its best if you move on to something else entirely, let Semi take care of the map, it doesnt need flashy secrets or extra minigames. There is something good about a map being simple, slowly evolving instead of randomly being crammed with massive secrets and games. There is no coherent vision in your design choices.

I also don't like that you called it a remake despite it being a port, its not even an overhaul, to me this feels like youre just piggybacking off a successful map, you don't even mention Semi in gamebanana credits, despite this version clearly building on his version.

I am sorry if this sounds kind of mean, but this is the third most popular map, in one of the most popular servers in the entire game. I would much rather stick with the maps current caretaker.
We want to reward mapmakers for their time and effort, but this isnt it.