Declined replace jb_supermario_v16e with b2 (1 Viewer)

[Rebelore]

JB_SUPERMARIO_REMAKE [Team Fortress 2] [Mods]

A Team Fortress 2 (TF2) Mod in the Jailbreak category, submitted by ReBeLore

gamebanana.com

 

[Expired]

supermario if it was a good map

 

[Rebelore]

@Mehgend

I forgot rhe poll hep

 

[NyanBat]

supermario if it was a good map

*WRONG INCORRECT BUZZER* it will never be good, its too overplayed to actually enjoy it.

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

Added a poll.

 

[SirKrookodile]

After testing the map in my own time, it's alright. Main issue is with the placement of some of the new minigames. Dodge Course and Car Game are pretty much entirely hidden. Some extra signage would allow people new to map to know those minigames even exist.

Although I see no reason not to add the map. From what I can tell it seems to function as intended, just needs some extra polish.

 

[BunniWitch]

if its functionally the same with just more no reason not to imo

 

[hehe troll]

no. never replace a functionally good map with a map that is actively in development. b2 means beta2, which means it has chances for bugs and whatnot.

 

[hehe troll]

nothing toward Rebel btw, i just think it needs to be playtested roughly first before addition

 

[Sym]

add it cuz i said so

 

[Bananawastaken]

Supermario is a community favourite so I’m going to hold it to a higher standard.

The map feels a bit too gimmicky and unpolished, the new secrets introduce massive balance problems, IE the deathrune pipe secret giving a large ammo box PLUS a ESCAPE is kind of insane

The map didnt need new minigames, I wouldnt have minded an extra secret in the jeoprady area but this is too much.

 

[SirKrookodile]

Did some more playtesting and this does require a lot more work to be put into it, new knowledge in regards to map secrets, a lot of them lack polish and or are too overpowered for how easy they are. A lot of breakables only take a couple melee hits to break. Going into dr hitting a breakable once and being able to get full ammo and a tp away is way tol powerful, especially when the ammo respawns and the tp can be used infinitely. This map needs more work before replacing our current version which is extremely popular in our current map pool, it being in the top 5 most played.

 

[Eagle_attack]

good map ngl, Surf and dodge course are a bit challenging but i think it will get easier the more you play it.

Ill vote yes for this one

 

[Musisphaera]

I'm voting no simply for adding weight to the suggestion.
As hehe already typed:

no. never replace a functionally good map with a map that is actively in development. b2 means beta2, which means it has chances for bugs and whatnot.

And what Banana and Krook are points which could either make or break a very popular map (the reason why it's so popular I do not know but I respect it being a good map).

I rather wish it first the problems be fixed, tested and then playtested by various members first before it goes into publishing.
This to avoid reverting to the earlier version + to have it become an RTV fodder.

It could become a yes if the map is at the standard of what we're currently having.

 

[BritishMafia]

I didnt get to attend the playtest so if there's another one I'll vote, but right now I don't really care either way.

 

[LilSpaceMan]

mid tbh mlcastle is better lowk (this is lie)
I would like to see a playtest before I vote

 

[MoonRise]

It looks decent enough, and with more playtesting and polish , it could be a top 5 map
Also, cant say no to more minigames to one of our most favorite maps

 

[vei]

Add? Maybe. Replace? Not yet. Voting no on this one.

 

[Kron]

I'd be okay with adding it to the rotation but until some of the bugs are sorted out I would not like it to replace the current supermario.

 

[hehe troll]

is the idea to replace the current supermario or to have both in rotation at the same time? if the latter is the case, maybe a name change for the CS port from Rebel would be nice