Accepted Player report on GreenShadow (1 Viewer)

[BON_]

Name: GreenShadow
SteamID: STEAM_0:0:807242502
What server/gamemode: US / Jailbreak
Any useful links such as their HLStats profile / SourceBans search:
HLSTATS PROFILE SOURCEBANS (0) SOURCECOMMS (0)

Rules broken:
False orders

Evidence: Attached below

Warden's order was for 2 blues to follow them but the reds followed the warden instead due to Greenshadow giving false orders at the same time

 

[GreenShadows]

noticing this, I do wish to apologize that i could not hear the warden myself and i should have stayed off the mic waiting for wardens orders, i do wish to quote from rules On Warden "
The Warden has the rights to request players to stay off the microphone to help himself giving clear orders, you can kill Red players talking through your orders if you give a warning first.
But you cannot restrict players to be muted for the entire round, you can request 30 seconds or the the entire start of the round to speak for yourself as Warden.". I listened to the video plenty of times and despite my knowing i was in the wrong there was the option for warden to enable overtalk or say at the very least that he wanted me off mic for 30 seconds so he can give clear orders, YuckleTTV was also seen talking in the video and warden did not tell him or us to be quiet meanwhile he was talking in a soft tone manner. I would have listened to him and stayed quiet if i actually heard him loud and clear as a warden should be if he wishes not to use overtalk or ask for silence

 

[GreenShadows]

I do also wish to quote another rule under warden - --"If the Warden chooses to use a guard to lead players to an area he must first obtain permission from that guard to do so. You may also not order a guard to stand in a disadvantageous position without similar permission." --- Reading this and looking at the footage the warden was requesting two random blu's to follow him without asking anyone specific so im not sure if that's an invalid order that he's been consistently giving out in the video. And also towards the end Yuckle was also proving how quiet the warden was being by ignoring his requests and instead answering from a text about someone asking for an admin on blu, very obviously displaying that the warden was unable to be heard because he spoke in a low soft tone

 

[SirKrookodile]

I do also wish to quote another rule under warden - --"If the Warden chooses to use a guard to lead players to an area he must first obtain permission from that guard to do so. You may also not order a guard to stand in a disadvantageous position without similar permission." --- Reading this and looking at the footage the warden was requesting two random blu's to follow him without asking anyone specific so im not sure if that's an invalid order that he's been consistently giving out in the video. And also towards the end Yuckle was also proving how quiet the warden was being by ignoring his requests and instead answering from a text about someone asking for an admin on blu, very obviously displaying that the warden was unable to be heard because he spoke in a low soft tone

He wasn't using them to lead reds anywhere, a warden can requests for blues to accompany them. That's an entirely different ballpark. He's asking for two blues to stick with him for protection. It's not a disadvantageous position to be in as they're all able to protect eachother.
The warden being unable to be heard does not allow you as a guard to give orders on the wardens behalf.
I'll be accepting this. Thank you Bon for reporting.