Completed [JB] It's Finally Time. I Want HHH Gone. (1 Viewer)

[Fairbee]

For people who voted no.

I don't get this lr as fun. You will be deaf after hearing the earrape multiple times, loud and needs to go.

 

[Semicolon Backslash]

(Assuming this is the plugin panda uses)

The plugin appears to have an option to disable all of the HHH sound effects. This doesn't fix the round delay but should fix people's problems with the sound effect spam.

 

[PistolPoppinSince02]

literally half of the reasons you presented in the thread is it takes too long.

so in the event it gets shortened, it sucks because its too loud? that's why you want it gone? I'm confused because volume is genuinely a non issue in basically every degree

This is my thesis "No this LR isn't broken like Shovel Day was, it just sucks."
Because it does.

 

[Valen]

(Assuming this is the plugin panda uses)

View attachment 35301

The plugin appears to have an option to disable all of the HHH sound effects. This doesn't fix the round delay but should fix people's problems with the sound effect spam.

can we just do this? this one's a classic I don't really want it gone

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

(Assuming this is the plugin panda uses)

View attachment 35301

The plugin appears to have an option to disable all of the HHH sound effects. This doesn't fix the round delay but should fix people's problems with the sound effect spam.

Because my post got deleted that had to pertain with the suggestion.

We are suggesting to remove a plugin based on issues that have very clearly obvious solutions that are in the config as well as a suggestion that is to shorten round timers coming soon.

Why don’t we just implement the issue fixes instead of removing the LR?

 

[Mehgend]

Why don’t we just implement the issue fixes instead of removing the LR?

Thats what im saying!!! We've had a few decent suggestions that got killed entirely because they were temporarily pushed aside because "we're suggesting a potential solution on a different thread" such as overtalk cool down and removing minecraft, neither of which ever got completed because desire for those changes died & the solutions did not work out. Now we are still suffering the downsides that both suggestions were removing.

Why can't we do the same with this? It's really inconsistent and has legit only done the complete opposite of what I wanted lmfao

 

[Musisphaera]

I am willing to change my vote IF the sound problem Semi provided a fix for can be used.
If the sound problem cannot be fixed, my vote remains yes.
I honestly could care less about the time issue. Even if it means I am stuck in spectator for 10 minutes. I could care less.
My problem with this LR is the extreme loud noises, as per my original comment.

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

I am willing to change my vote IF the sound problem Semi provided a fix for can be used.
If the sound problem cannot be fixed, my vote remains yes.
I honestly could care less about the time issue. Even if it means I am stuck in spectator for 10 minutes. I could care less.
My problem with this LR is the extreme loud noises, as per my original comment.

Just vote to keep it, and surely the admin team can take note of the complaints of the volume and change the config.

We do not live in a time where updates take months, they can fix this LR super quickly.

 

[Cowboy]

I'd be okay with the LR staying if the sounds were adjusted and the round timer cut down.

The only thing that bothers me is the jankiness of the lr itself, the hitboxes are quite all over the place and it can feel frustrating. Maybe thats why people like it? Dunno.

 

[Madact]

Could split the suggestion poll votes 3 ways:

Yes. Remove the LR
No but remove sound
No and keep the sound

Any issues with that or is it unnecessary at this stage?

To some here I can see it's not just about the music / stomping sound. One reason is about delaying, which we will be working on reducing these special LRs down to 5 mins as part of this suggestion
As for the 'it's boring' point fair enough. I can understand that the melee in it can be wonky and there's not much variety especially when it compares to other battle lrs such as hungergames.

 

[Valen]

Could split the suggestion poll votes 3 ways:

Yes. Remove the LR
No but remove sound
No and keep the sound

Any issues with that or is it unnecessary at this stage?

To some here I can see it's not just about the music / stomping sound. One reason is about delaying, which we will be working on reducing these special LRs down to 5 mins as part of this suggestion
As for the 'it's boring' point fair enough. I can understand that the melee in it can be wonky and there's not much variety especially when it compares to other battle lrs such as hungergames.

That might split the vote. Maybe just have the two options of

Yes. Remove the LR
No, but remove the sound


removing the sound is a net positive imo

 

[Sunsob]

I think if the volume of the round gets lowered and the timer gets reduced it's fine to keep. I still won't exactly love it but I don't think it would be worth removing with these changes.

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

I don’t think we should split in 3 ways. The major issue said with everyone is volume and with what valen said, its just a net positive.

Reseting the poll would be nice given how there is new information regarding a fix and typically people don’t look back at the forum after voting.

 

[PistolPoppinSince02]

Listen guys, you can make the LR as functional as you want and "fix" it, but the LR is still just not fun.
As I said in the first post;
"No this LR isn't broken like Shovel Day was, it just sucks."
You can polish a turd all you want, but all you'll have is a shiny turd.

For those whose primary concern was the noise, a solution has been offered so that concern of yours should be null going forward.

 

[Musisphaera]

For those whose primary concern was the noise, a solution has been offered so that concern of yours should be null going forward.

Then this changes the suggestion for me.
If the possible sound solution is fixed, Im voting no then.

 

[Madact]

Poll reset, please revote again. Check discussion for more information

@_Black @koe @haze @Bananawastaken @BunniWitch @kiwyko @Rage0Active @Koduturott @CheemsGaming @Nergal Nergalton @PistolPoppinSince02 @Cowboy @maxolotl @LottaFazion @RevivalDan @PFD1 @Socks @SirKrookodile @jcal @SanorXoars @KyePerson @soirb @Eagle_attack @BritishMafia @Fairbee @Expired @T0aster
@Valen @hehe troll @Semicolon Backslash @Mehgend @Sunsob @salguod @LilSpaceMan @ItsNotCalassic @Dr. Meatloaf @Ahamkara's Vow @cilantro @crubf @Eryas @pinecone @Musisphaera @NyanBat @whale heavy @BON_ @GRNBEAN

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

Listen guys, you can make the LR as functional as you want and "fix" it, but the LR is still just not fun.
As I said in the first post;
"No this LR isn't broken like Shovel Day was, it just sucks."
You can polish a turd all you want, but all you'll have is a shiny turd.

For those whose primary concern was the noise, a solution has been offered so that concern of yours should be null going forward.

Would want to point out once again if your concern is also about long round times during this LR, the suggestion regarding shorter special LR round timers is in the works of being implemented as well!

 

[Dr. Meatloaf]

I don’t think that an LR not being fun is enough to justify its removal. Personally I don’t really think that Meele Only Day, Baby Day, or Low-Gravity day are fun LRs. I honestly don’t really think HHH is super fun either, and I’ve never chosen it as an LR myself.

However it’s a good thing to have a lot of variety with LRs both so that JB stays interesting and so that LR recipients can get the most out of the LR by choosing whatever LR they enjoy most.

In order to remove an LR in my eyes it needs to be so fundamentally broken that it’s a truly miserable experience for most people on the server like market garden day was. Now that the sound and round time are being fixed I don’t think there is any argument that HHH is so fundamentally bad as to justify removal.

 

[whale heavy]

I think its funny and i dont want it gone

 

[Bananawastaken]

Removing the HHH sound has been added to the pending pool