Declined [Jb] Allow LR-only minigames to be done on last round alongside Warday (1 Viewer)

[Nergal Nergalton]

I propose to allow wardens to do minigames restricted to LR only, both custom and on certain maps, on last round alongside of Warday. This includes the following:
- Hunger Games
- Hide and Seek
- Simon Says
- Meatgrinder
- Doomsday (District)
- Jojo (Lunapark)
- VS Sentry (Underjail)

All except Simon Says are very similar to Warday in that they all involve the mass slaughtering of REDs, which has the same restrictions. We allow wardens to do a “last warday” if there is less than 2 minutes remaining before mapchange on round start. Why not these ones? I also believe it to be a fair compromise to those who want Simon Says unbanned.

 

[BritishMafia]

I feel like it would be simpler to just say BLU's can do LR only minigames on the last round. My only problem with this is it might be confusing, and might lead to people arguing on if it's allowed or not.
Also with warday, the only thing stopping them from doing it is the warden, but if I tried to do Doomsday on the last day, it only takes one red scurrying off and now there's gonna be 6 minute delay.
I won't vote for now tho.

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

I feel like it would be simpler to just say BLU's can do LR only minigames on the last round. My only problem with this is it might be confusing, and might lead to people arguing on if it's allowed or not.
Also with warday, the only thing stopping them from doing it is the warden, but if I tried to do Doomsday on the last day, it only takes one red scurrying off and now there's gonna be 6 minute delay.
I won't vote for now tho.

Adjusted.

 

[hehe troll]

I propose to allow wardens to do minigames restricted to LR only, both custom and on certain maps, on last round alongside of Warday. This includes the following:
- Hunger Games
- Hide and Seek
- Simon Says
- Meatgrinder
- Doomsday (District)
- Jojo (Lunapark)
- VS Sentry (Underjail)

All except Simon Says are very similar to Warday in that they all involve the mass slaughtering of REDs, which has the same restrictions. We allow wardens to do a “last warday” if there is less than 2 minutes remaining before mapchange on round start. Why not these ones? I also believe it to be a fair compromise to those who want Simon Says unbanned.

honestly?... neutral

let me explain my reasoning,
so arguments why im in favor:
- these LR only minigames could spice up the overall rounds if none have been done for the entire round duration
- the warden doesn't have to do any of these, they can just do a normal round if they so please
- these games do give some variety on the things we can do on the last round, id be more than willing to give Simon Says a spin or two

so arguments why im against:
- i feel like it could cause some really big confusion on what minigames are and aren't allowed, it'd have to be clearly and non-vaguely specified in the rules what counts as an "lr only minigame" because does "Climb with ff killing is kos" count? it's LR only sooo that technically means i can do it!
- it'd give the warden too many options, and maybe overwhelm them
- if one "last day special LR" round that starts at 1:59 and ends at 1:20 due to warden getting overwhelmed by reds, does that mean the warden can either redo that LR, or just outright start a new LR round since the round timer is still below 2? that could cause some confusion too
- i can see hide & seek being a potential delayfest, especially if people reaaallyyy want to go to the next map already... just imagine if the current map gets extended and you do hide & seek as the last round, dragging it on for 10 more painful and agonizing minutes of waiting. (im oberall not really a big fan of h&s but that's something for another time)
- honestly i kind of like the aggressiveness of laat day warday, it isn't too boring and it can definitely cause the last round to feel climactic in a way, where as all the other lrs just kinda. eh?

 

[Bananawastaken]

The reason why last day Warday is a thing is because it near guarantees the end of the map. And also, no LR is given, it’s ending the map on a blast and quickly rotating to the next one.

Letting people do normal round LRs that can end super quick defeats the entire point.

 

[crubf]

All except Simon Says are very similar to Warday in that they all involve the mass slaughtering of REDs, which has the same restrictions.

reds can fight back on warday. tehy have guns

We allow wardens to do a “last warday” if there is less than 2 minutes remaining before mapchange on round start. Why not these ones?

because its a way to just skip to the next map since war days usually do not take very long to conclude. u are on the other hand suggesting allowing shit that can tak e the entire round timer to not even complete. or maybe barely finish.
very exciting to do a 9 minute hns round (im dead 3 minutes in) to not even get a real LR.

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

Would it be more preferable to allow only the map minigames that are LR only? (Doomsday, Jojo, and VS Sentry) instead?

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

I believe this should be voted on a minigame basis as opposed to a large group for yes or no.


I agree with some of these, but not hide and seek for example

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

Added a third option to do only the map-specific LR only games.

Perfectly understand the concerns with the custom LRs, but I don’t think it would be a bad idea to allow the map-specific games.
Doomsday is pretty much Warday with aliens and pickups, and doesn’t end in LR either. Jojo is one BLU slaughtering the REDs in an enclosed area. And VS Sentry is pretty quick regardless of outcome, minus the bugged platform.

 

[ItsNotCalassic]

Added a third option to do only the map-specific LR only games.

This will only split the vote and seems like an unneccessary addition considering the fact that you added it, after like 14 people have voted...

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

Gonna prematurely close this and rework this suggestion.