Declined [JB] Add jb_supermario_remake in tandem instead of replacing v16e (1 Viewer)

[pot_head_wabbit]

Recently there was a forum suggestion to replace jb_supermario_v16e with jb_supermario_remake_b2, while there's not too many glaring bugs that needed to be fixed in b1 compared to b2 there was still enough bugs to not make it feasible to add the map at that current moment. The main argument people had against not adding it currently was because the forum suggestion was to replace the old version outright, this was not received too well as most of the people who play panda are used to the old version of super Mario that has been running with almost no changes for 3+ years. I am proposing a middle ground solution where panda for a brief period runs both maps at the same time and gauge the players reactions to both b2 and v16e (after a playtest on the panda unofficial discord is ran for b2.) By the end of the test period, if it's clear by the end b2 is truly an upgrade and the people prefer it then keep that one. If not remove b2 and only run v16e till rebelore can refine super Mario remake into the superior map it can be compared to the original.

JB_SUPERMARIO_REMAKE [Team Fortress 2] [Mods]

A Team Fortress 2 (TF2) Mod in the Jailbreak category, submitted by ReBeLore

gamebanana.com

 

[SirKrookodile]

No. Far too similar to be in rotation together.
Once remake gets fully cleaned up and is ready for our servers then we can talk about replacing our current version of supermario with it. But what we won't do is have 2 of the same map in rotation. Nobody wants to spend 4 map rotations in a row on what is essentially the same map.

 

[pot_head_wabbit]

No. Far too similar to be in rotation together.
Once remake gets fully cleaned up and is ready for our servers then we can talk about replacing our current version of supermario with it. But what we won't do is have 2 of the same map in rotation. Nobody wants to spend 4 map rotations in a row on what is essentially the same map.

speak for yourself

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

I don't really like the idea of a map and it's remake co-existing together in our pool unless the remake is vastly different enough from the original (which it almost never is), it makes it redundant. A long time ago we had both v8 and v12 of Hopjb in our map pool and that's exactly what happened.

 

[PistolPoppinSince02]

Yeah it's gotta be one or the other in my opinion.
No, sorry.

 

[PENZTRIKA]

Don't think people would be happy if Mario maps could be in constant rotation considering you can't nominate a map after 3 maps and if there's 4 maps, it could end up just being mario 24/7

 

[BritishMafia]

Stop I dont wanna play mario I want to play tf2 STOP ADDING MARIO MAPS!!!!

 

[NyanBat]

Don't think people would be happy if Mario maps could be in constant rotation considering you can't nominate a map after 3 maps and if there's 4 maps, it could end up just being mario 24/7

that seems to be exactly what he wants

 

[JulieAntarctica]

can Dupe Supermario_v16 twice and get the same experience

 

[Ahamkara's Vow]

I hate the mario maps (Galaxy is fine) constantly getting played. IMO they are overplayed. Everytime one of them gets nominated it will win the map vote which leads to alot of the map pool being barely touched. I want to play more maps like Underjail or Jailfort.

 

[NyanBat]

i see we're back to farming negative reaction scores

 

[solid soirb]

we get it you like the mario maps jesus....

 

[Expired]

bait used to be believable

 

[Semicolon Backslash]

I am proposing a middle ground solution where panda for a brief period runs both maps at the same time and gauge the players reactions to both b2 and v16e

 

[JulieAntarctica]

extend map is an option

 

[BritishMafia]

another thing is why are we not letting the map creators, who know when the map is done, suggest the map???
you're nobody's knight in shining armor, these people know how to type a suggestion

 

[Fairy]

“Dont worry lil jailbreak player, uncle mapper has enough jb_supermario remakes to feed you for the rest of your life”

“FORUM SUGGESTOR! bring more duplicate maps, the boys hungry”

 

[SirKrookodile]

Poll results speak for themselves.
Declining prematurely due to overwhelmingly negative votes.