Accepted USJB Report (1 Viewer)

[bap!]

Dr. Meatloaf
STEAM_0:1:173143725

Panda Community HLstatsX - Panda-Community.com US | Jailbreak - Player Details - Dr.Meatloaf

hlstats.panda-community.com

US-JB
Rules broken : Round Delay
Evidence : video below

 

[Dr. Meatloaf]

Ok, I definetly didn't think that somebody would actually report me for this, and I apoligize because me saying on video "an admin won't ban me for this" makes me sound arrogent as fuck. With that said I think what I did made sense given the situation, and it seems to fall in a gray area within the rules. Please let me explain.

JB Rule: "Prisoners are also entitled to a Death Request (DR) after they have chosen their LR. The DR must take a maximum of 2 minutes to prevent delaying, if it lasts longer the Warden can end the round by killing them."

Seeing as the warden essentially denied the prisoner's right to DR by killing himself with the soccer ball (as shown in the video) I thought it was best to give the prisoner a death request anyway.

JB Rule: The last Guard alive in team BLU may kill all the remaining Red players including Freedays, this means that all the Red players can't be "freekilled" by this Guard.

The wording "The last guard alive on team BLU mau kill all the remaining Red players" seems to indicate that in some situations it's not appropriate to immedietly kill the last player such as a warden denying DR. Especially when this wording is compared to the rules regarding rebellers "guards have to kill rebellers" it becomes more clear that LGKA can depend on the situation.

JB Rule: " Guards have to kill Rebellers as they are a dangerous threat to the Warden.

If someone earns a Rebeller status you are free to kill that Rebeller even if the Warden forbids you to do so."

If I'm wrong or not understanding the rules correctly that's fine, but as of now I still don't think what I did warrents punishment.

 

[bap!]

Hi meatloaf, I do agree that this does fall in the gray area of the rules.

The main reason I reported you was because at the time me and other people in the chat (shown in the video) were telling you to just kill them so the round wouldn't last another minute since it didn't have too. I feel like you could've taken this differently by just killing the person and moving onto the next round but everyone treats LGKA differently so thats understandable. In the end this is up to whichever full handles this report but now as im thinking about it as long as you learned your lesson I don't really see a reason to guardban you.

Anyways, thats all I really have to say. Goodbye B)

 

[Semicolon Backslash]

Seeing as the warden essentially denied the prisoner's right to DR by killing himself with the soccer ball (as shown in the video) I thought it was best to give the prisoner a death request anyway.

I won't contest that, bob was being an idiot by deciding to play with a soccer ball that can kill you, still doesn't change the fact it's last guard kills all.

The wording "The last guard alive on team BLU mau kill all the remaining Red players" seems to indicate that in some situations it's not appropriate to immedietly kill the last player such as a warden denying DR. Especially when this wording is compared to the rules regarding rebellers "guards have to kill rebellers" it becomes more clear that LGKA can depend on the situation.

If you're really going to use this "may kill all" as an excuse then by that logic I don't ever have to ever LGKA as its completely up to my discretion on if I want to kill people or not. The point of lgka is to end the round and prevent delay giving him a dr did the opposite of this.


Accepted, thank you for the report.