Declined [JB] LR idea: Random melee for all (1 Viewer)

[Spongejoe]

at the start of the round everyone gets a random melee

and yes it is apparently possible

 

[Koduturott]

no thanks

 

[PistolPoppinSince02]

Say it with me now, melee lrs are BORING.

"But everyone has a random melee"!
Yeah and they're all going to do the same thing, walk at people.

Random Weapons (i.e a full loadout) would be neat.
Getting a chance to rebel to see what's in the box, while blu scatters around with whatever they were given.

That could be fun. This? Hard hard pass.

 

[Spongejoe]

Say it with me now, melee lrs are BORING.

"But everyone has a random melee"!
Yeah and they're all going to do the same thing, walk at people.

Random Weapons (i.e a full loadout) would be neat.
Getting a chance to rebel to see what's in the box, while blu scatters around with whatever they were given.

That could be fun. This? Hard hard pass.

so warday with random loadout then

 

[bird7th]

This lr would be really underwhelming and boring in an actual match.

Sure it might be fun in some scenarios but I think everybody on the blue team would just switch to demoknight (since almost no demoman meele is bad) the second they see this being picked.

Also the chance of this lr being picked is really low (due to how boring and simple it sounds) compared to other available lrs out there, something like random weapons (randomizing every weapon in your loadout,as suggested by pistolpoppin above) rather than only random meele weapons would be a more interesting idea.

But I can see a little bit of potential if executed right,worked upon or combined with other existing lrs or ideas!

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

Added a poll.

 

[Eagle_attack]

better than rapid rockets

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

A full randomized loadout day would be more interesting than just melee. There are only a few certain melees (Eureka Effect, Wrap Assassin, Knife) that would actually be interesting to see other classes besides their own have.

 

[GreenShadows]

to be honest, i've been thinking about this one since i first saw it,The only thing i could think was warden just needing to tell everyone with wrap, No Projectiles, But what about stuff like "spies have your sappers out" ??. The whole point for it is to prevent warden and blus from getting backstabbed but if the knife is given to a scout and just goes on a spree or a heavy, What would have other Classes have to switch to since most of them can't even have a secondary like soldier they can switch out to to avoid having knifes out?

Also it seems like a bad trade for the blue team since most of them use their Primary or secondary anyways, giving them a Melee like the heavies Fist of steel* could nerf them and make it useless ultimately for the blue team as well.

 

[Uncle Bob]

if its just random melees then there is no point but its a full loadout then it would actually very fun.

 

[Uncle Bob]

melee would just be boring cause half the time ur getting a reskin of stock.

 

[HIMA_]

got an idea
decline this idea and remove melee only LR
so we can use guns in peace

 

[Eagle_attack]

Declined Thread 'Randomized loadout Day / Warday LR'

Dec 17, 2024

Greetings.

I have an LR idea, Randomized Loadout day LR

If this LR works we can also do Randomized loadout WARDAY!

So the point is everyone has a different load out so example:

Red
-Scout with a Knife
-Heavy with boston basher
-demoman with wrap assasin
-Medic with a Flamethrower ( if guns on red team work!)

Blue
-Sniper with a Minigun
-Pyro with Jarate
-Spy with a Shotgun
-Engineer with Medi-gun

-I'm just not sure if the guns will work for the RED team...

• Eagle_attack
• Replies: 8
• Forum: Archive

• 

Maybe we can make it work this time

 

[Nergal Nergalton]

Declined Thread 'Randomized loadout Day / Warday LR'

Dec 17, 2024

Greetings.

I have an LR idea, Randomized Loadout day LR

If this LR works we can also do Randomized loadout WARDAY!

So the point is everyone has a different load out so example:

Red
-Scout with a Knife
-Heavy with boston basher
-demoman with wrap assasin
-Medic with a Flamethrower ( if guns on red team work!)

Blue
-Sniper with a Minigun
-Pyro with Jarate
-Spy with a Shotgun
-Engineer with Medi-gun

-I'm just not sure if the guns will work for the RED team...

• Eagle_attack
• Replies: 8
• Forum: Archive

• 

Maybe we can make it work this time

You can resuggest that if you want since it's been more than a year.

 

[Eagle_attack]

You can resuggest that if you want since it's been more than a year.

Ill ask berke first

 

[PFD1]

bro how can ya'll not want this but have a caber melee only as an lr

 

[HIMA_]

bro how can ya'll not want this but have a caber melee only as an lr

cuz you can bomb guards with it!!!

 

[PistolPoppinSince02]

bro how can ya'll not want this but have a caber melee only as an lr

THAT SHIT SUCKS TOO
I'M TIRED OF MELEE SLOP LRS

 

[Mehgend]

Declining due to poll results