Recent content by cilantro

I think a plugin based lr solution (something like forced taunting for reds or turning on outlines for reds if it takes too long) would be a much better solution for hns than a rule like this. Obviously someone would have to make it but I would rather wait for that.

I feel like regardless of whether these should be added or not there shouldn't be 5 LRs in a single thread, and that each LR should be a single thread. Each of these LRs are pretty complex and I don't think they can all be fully discussed when they're jammed like this.

Most classes just can't deal with buildings efficiently, especially at range, meaning that it would encourages blue team to use soldier/demo more which would definitely lead to more free kills. Buildings also have crit immunity so it just completely negates blue team's main advantage too, which...

personally i don't really enjoy this map either but i don't think any of the reasons given are strong enough for the map to be removed. i feel like a lot of the points you made could describe lots of maps in rotation like casuarina, stormfront, albany, etc. if people are mostly annoyed with...

I've heard this complaint alot yet genuinely "closest minigames to cells" syndrome can describe countless maps, as it's the reason inexperienced wardens do things like mass russian roulette on causarina or spam death run on minecraft nightfall. When compared to other maps even the three games...

Isn't this considered encouraging rule breaking? People are already punished for trying to get wardens to do illegal orders.

I think forcing wardens to do LRs without the illegal part is really difficult on them, as most wardens probably don't have every rule memorized, and might not make as good judgement as an admin on what is legal. Personally I sometimes already struggle remembering some obscure rules as warden...

i honestly sort of disagree. i don't have objective evidence but i feel like pokemon day has been having sort of a resurgence recently, and because its getting picked as an lr more it naturally its causing more conversations about it. it feels similar to when ff all day/mass trivia had...

I feel like this lr would be wildly unfair to blus, to the point where it instantly causes failrounds and sort of negates the lr. At least in guards melee only blues still have an advantage over reds with guaranteed crits, but with this LR the reds could rush the blus and win every time.

I like the idea but I don't see why it has to be done in November (besides the alliteration?). I think it would make much more sense to do an event like this during the summer when a lot of people are completely off from school.

Overall I think the quality/creativity of a JB map's minigames tends to be the biggest contributor to how much the map is played, and interwebz currently beats a vast majority of maps we have in rotation. For this alone I think it should be a no brainer to add this map.

I think I would rather have a hard cap. I know this "minigame" is only for hunting rebellers, but I wonder if blus are going to use this as a point farming exercise, looking for any excuse to kill a red. Alternatively, reds can also just volunteer their lives to extend the round a long time...

even if this suggestion passed, could it reasonably even be enforced? how is a blu who joins halfway through a map’s duration supposed to know which mini games were played the last 3 rounds before they joined?

does this plugin allow the warden to turn it off? i think the biggest advantage of cell wars was that it was completely optional, a team of 3 or fewer guards could challenge themselves and have fun managing a large red team. with this change i'm worried it could ruin this dynamic. i'm also...

i don't usually comment on suggestions but this one is seriously a drastic change to the server, echoing what Valen said here: lots of players have lots of jb experience from other communities, and they will be put off from joining if there is a blu timer. additionally with the new vpn...