Here are the final results:
Best Overall: ba_mlcastle_v10 stealing the title back from ba_hopjb_v8
Worst Overall: jb_xmf_v2 taking the title from both jb_underjail_b2 and jb_complex_b6
Best Minigames: ba_mlcastle_v10
Prettiest map: ba_amazonjungle_v4a taking the title from jb_district_a4fix, jb_lunapark_b2, ba_space_jail_v7, and jb_underjail_b2
Most Underrated: jb_district_a4fix forcefully removing the title from jb_stormfront_v6fix2, ba_jail_casuarina_b5_final2, and ba_space_jail_v7
Most Nostalgic: A three way tie between ba_jail_casuarina_b5_final2, jb_snowday_v9, and ba_mlcastle_v10
Longest Sitelines: jb_famouz_2_final_fixed
Worst Optimization: A tie between jb_hopjb_v11 and ba_amazonjungle_v4a
And now for the map vs map section:
Better map overall: jb_stormfront_v6fix2 beats jb_volcano_v1a
Most bland map: jb_complex_b6 barely beats jb_xmf_v2
Best 9square: jb_lunapark_b2 beats ba_jail_casuarina_b5_final2
Most balanced: jb_snowday_v9 beats ba_amazonjungle_v4a
Most fun to rebel on: jb_crossroads_final_fix4 barely beats jb_famouz_2_final_fixed
Thanks for voting and see you next year!